Fall Treats Around Greater Lafayette

Pumpkin Spice season is upon us! Of course, you can grab up a PSL at any Starbucks location, but these local favorite spots have some fun, creative Fall treats. Check out this list and decide which delicious treats you want to try in Greater Lafayette, IN.

Java Jo’z Coffee Shops

(Click here to view locations and hours!)

Come try any of these fun Java Jo’z flavor combinations for fun Fall treats: Iced Pumpkin Spice Latte with Pumpkin Cold Foam, Brown Sugar Cinnamon Latte, Brown Sugar Cinnamon Mocha Bianca, Spice Carmel Apple Cider, Carmel Sticky Bun, or Frozen Pumpkin Pie Mochaccino. Maybe you prefer your sweet treats to be in pastry form? Try the pumpkin spice scones, Rob’s special roasted almonds, The Homestead’s Pumpkin Chip Muffins, or a Charcuterie Girl snack boxes! Tell Rob and the gang we said hi!

Sacred Grounds: Reclaimed Coffee Shop 

(Click here to view location and hours!)

Sacred Grounds is a classic coffee shop with cozy corner feels that’ll make you want to stay forever. Come in for a standard pumpkin latte, a Dirty Pumpkin (iced or hot), or stay for lunch to try the Black & Gold or Smokey Apple Grilled Cheese Sandwiches. You’ll be so glad you visited these beautiful people.

  • Seasonal drinks
    • Dirty Pumpkin (pumpkin spice seasoning, chai, cinnamon, espresso, milk, topped with homemade whipped cream!)
    • Fire Tower (white chocolate, cayenne, and orange)
  • Seasonal lunch sandwiches 
    • Black and Gold (grilled cheese with black forest ham, sharp cheddar, spicy peach preserve, and caramelized onion)
    • Smokey Apple (grilled cheese with bacon, smoked gouda, thinly sliced apple, and caramelized onion!)
  • Snacks
    • Apple Fritter Muffins

Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. 

(Click here to view location and hours!)

With 2 current Purdue University Campus locations, Greyhouse Coffee Co. always stays a step ahead on their seasonal menu. We recommend trying them all. Bourbon Affogato, Apple Cider– Greyhouse gives us all the creative vibes. Check their seasonal crepes, donuts (such as the snickerdoodle), and gelato flavors while you’re in.

Igloo Frozen Custard 

(Click here to view location and hours!)

Igloo Frozen Custard is another Greater Lafayette, IN staple that EVERYONE loves. It’s the go-to place for any after game treat or fountain Coke in town. Try the season pumpkin daily treats that are posted on the board as you enter the drive thru. Yes, it’s old school, and that’s one way Igloo stays such an experience. There are 2 locations in our community!

Mammaw’s Sweet Shoppe 

(Click here to view location and hours!)

Mammaw really knows what she’s doin’ when it comes to her Fall treats. Million Dollar Bacon Pie (sweet or spicy), jumbo Fall painted sugar cookies, snickerdoodle, or pumpkin and apple are all on the menu, and we recommend every single one!

Sweet Revolution Bake Shop 

(Click here to view location and hours!)

Sweet Rev specializes in Fall’s favorite treat: pie. Traditional, pot pies, quiches, turnovers – you name the puff pastry treat, and they probably make deliciousness with it! Here are just a few examples of season-rich items they’ve had over the past few weeks. The menu constantly changes, so be sure to check in every week to see the revolving flavors! 

  • Seasonal Desserts
    • Pies
      • Ginger Blackberry Plum
      • White Chocolate Raspberry Pear
      • Caramel Apple
      • Sour Cream Apple 
    • Turnovers
      • Plum berry
      • Spiced Apple Pear
    • Pot Pies
      • Corn Squash Chowder
      • Herb Roasted Chicken

Mary Lou Donuts 

(Click here to view location and hours!)

Mary Lou’s is another Greater Lafayette, IN favorite. Now with 2 locations, you can get your favorite local donuts on either side of town! Bonus: keep your eyes open for the Mary Lou Food Truck at local events. Check out these seasonal flavors along with other sweet treats such as cookie decorating kits, caramel pop corn, and Carmel apples inside each location!

  • Seasonal Doughnut Flavors
    • Pumpkin Cake
    • Apple Spice Cake
    • Cinnamon sugar with apple filling (a Greater Lafayette, IN favorite!)
    • Pumpkin with cream cheese icing
  • Other season desserts
    • Carrot Cake Cupcakes with homemade cream cheese icing
    • Pumpkin Muffins
  • Drinks
    • S’mores hot chocolate with graham cracker topping


For up-to-date information on YOUR Indiana area neighborhood or a FREE Seller Consultation – call The Romanski Group at (765) 293.9300.  Using an experienced team is the way to get your home ‪SOLD‬! You deserve the BEST Real Estate Team in the Lafayette Indiana area!